Personal Welfare Deputyships
Personal Welfare Deputyships
Personal Welfare Deputy (PWD) is authorised by the Court of Protection to make decisions in relation to health and welfare matters on behalf of a person who has been assessed as lacking capacity to make these decisions themselves. PWDs are typically friends or family of the person (“P”), who know P well. Professionals such as Solicitors may also be appointed to act as personal welfare deputies. PWDs may be appointed individually, jointly, or jointly and severally. The scope and duration of their powers can be limited, expanded or revoked by the court.
In terms of when an application for PWD may be considered appropriate, there have previously been two distinct approaches. The first, being a more restrictive approach to deputyships, taken in Lawson by Hayden J, in which a PWD is considered appropriate only in exceptional circumstances; in ‘the most difficult cases’. The second, adopted by Poole J in Parr, is a more flexible approach, emphasising the importance of the engagement of families who may know P best.
These two approaches were considered by the Court of Appeal in Re HB (Appointment of Personal Welfare Deputy) [2026] EWCA Civ 960.
The Court of Appeal’s guidance: Re HB (Appointment of Personal Welfare Deputy) [2026] EWCA Civ 960
In July 2026, in its judgment in Re HB, the Court of Appeal provided clear guidance as to when the appointment of a PWD may be appropriate. In this judgment, the Court of Appeal unanimously overturned the judgment of HHJ Beckley in Re HDEB [2026] EWCOP 12. HHJ Beckley had refused the application of the appellants, JB and SB, to be appointed as PWDs for their son, HB. The Court of Appeal determined it was “satisfied on the material presented […] that [JB and SB] should, jointly and severally, be enabled to exercise the role of PWD in respect of a wide range of care and welfare issues […], subject to the conditions and restrictions as they are set out in the MCA 2005, for the foreseeable future.” [6]
HB, at the time of the judgment, was 22 years old. He has a severe learning disability, autism and is non-verbal in his communication. HB was assessed as lacking capacity in relation to personal welfare decisions. The judgment notes that HB’s parents had learned HB’s cues and manner of communication. JB and SB are described as committed, loving and caring parents. Interestingly, there had been no opposition to the parents’ application to be PWDs for HB. The application had been supported by HB’s aunt, his school and the chief executive officer of a national autism charity that knew HB.
In their deputyship application, SB and JB sought authority in relation to the following:
- Consenting to medical and/or dental examination and treatment on his behalf;
- Choosing where and with whom he should live, in accordance with section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act 2005, limited to choosing from available options from any public authority;
- The provision of care services;
- Matters of day-to-day care, including diet and dress
- Whether he should take part in work placement opportunities, leisure or social activities; and
- Making and conducting complaints about his care or treatment.
These were noted to be standard decisions granted to PWDs.
In rejecting their application, HHJ Beckley follows the more restrictive approach to deputyships taken in Lawson, placing an emphasis on HB’s autonomy and the role of collaborative decision making between professionals and HB’s family.
In contrast, the Court of Appeal’s judgment places an emphasis on promoting the dignity and quality of life for P, which enhances P’s autonomy. Moreover, it challenged HHJ Beckley’s conclusions as, similarly to the facts in Parr, HB’s parents had experienced a number of difficulties dealing with statutory bodies in respect of HB’s welfare throughout his life.
Why is this case important?
The Court of Appeal’s judgment provides helpful guidance for those considering applications for the appointment of Personal Welfare Deputies in the Court of Protection.
When determining whether their appointment may be appropriate, the following considerations may be had:
- Does the proposed deputy have a special relationship/understanding of P's communication
- Would the appointment of a PWD likely enhance P's wishes and feelings, values and beliefs, providing for person-centred decision making
- Where a series of decisions are likely required.
- When P is transitioning from children's to adult's services.
- Where there is (potential) failure of public bodies to apply the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
- Where decision making needs to be prompt and agile in response to changing circumstances.
It is important to note that this is not an exhaustive list of considerations, nor a compulsory checklist for PWDs to be appointed.
What does it mean for families?
For many people, this judgment provides welcomed guidance for families who may know P best and wish to be appointed as personal welfare deputies. It provides clarity, validation and hope for family members as well as clear and structured guidance as to when the appointment of a PWD may be considered appropriate.
How Butler and Co can help
At Butler and Co, we provide legal advice in relation to applications for deputyship, for both property and financial affairs, and health and welfare. We advise on the merits of an application and the likelihood of any challenge against an application. We are able to help families understand what they'd be able to do, what powers they could exercise and what limitations there are to the scope of their appointment.
At Butler and Co Solicitors, we offer a competitive fixed rate for deputyship applications, both for personal welfare and property and affairs. We are able to advise deputies on their duties and provide advice to individuals who have been appointed to act as deputies.
Please contact us to find out more.